St John the Divine supports two choirs:

The Choristers of St. John the Divine sing at most Sunday morning services, and the monthly Choral Evensong, offering motets, anthems, and mass settings from the Sacred Classical canon, with an emphasis on music of the English Church. The membership of the Choristers includes long-standing parishioners, as well as many students from UVic and The Conservatory.

The Community Choir sings once monthly, offering an anthem and a psalm setting, and welcomes all who have an ear for a tune and a passion for music in liturgy.